Nathaniel Hawthorne's Twice-Told Tales: A Guide

Twice-Told Tales

Shadows of colonial New England, where reality is occasionally interrupted by ghosts, madness, and very stubborn men.

Author
by Nathaniel Hawthorne
Type
collection · Short Fiction
Published
1837
Length
Short story collection
Status
Public domain
Twice-Told Tales summary

What's Inside

This collection gathers various accounts of colonial life, where historical record blends into psychological unease. Hawthorne surveys New England, documenting figures like a soldier of King James II, a man who abandons his house for two decades to watch it from the next street, and a family gathered in the Notch of the White Hills. Whether tracking religious outcasts, treasure-seekers in the White Mountains, or the rituals of a Shaker settlement, the narratives remain tethered to the weight of inherited burdens and the strange, quiet shifts in domestic fate. Each piece acts as a ledger of regional memory, moving between the moral texture of the past and the sudden, unasked-for interventions that steer a human life.

Twice-Told Tales people

Works & figures

  • Sir Edmund Andros

    A stern governor who forces his will on colonial residents. (in “The Gray Champion”)

  • Wakefield

    A man who leaves his marriage for two decades of silence. (in “Wakefield”)

  • David Swan

    A traveler whose life is shaped by accidents he never notices. (in “David Swan”)

  • Father Ephraim

    A dying Shaker elder who must select his community's new leader. (in “The Shaker Bridal”)

Twice-Told Tales themes & meaning

What it's really about

Moral inheritance
Past actions defining the present life.
Seclusion
Isolation as both a choice and a prison.

Why it's memorable

  • A gilded Indian sentinel, bow bent and arrow drawn, stands fixed atop the Province House, aiming eternally at the weathercock on the Old South Church spire.
  • A mountain family laughing before a landslide changes everything.
Twice-Told Tales bottom line

Where to start

Start with The Great Carbuncle to see how Hawthorne balances the absurdity of human greed against the vast indifference of the White Mountains.

Twice-Told Tales discussion questions

For your book club

  1. Is Wakefield's decades-long absence a mental break or a cruel experiment?
  2. Does the author prefer historical myth or the quiet misery of neighbors?
Books like Twice-Told Tales

If you liked this