Sherlock Holmes: The Comeback Tour

The Return of Sherlock Holmes

A detective returns from the dead. His friend is thrilled. The villains, less so.

Author
by Arthur Conan Doyle
Type
Short stories · Detective Fiction
Published
1905
Length
Short stories
Status
Public domain
The Return of Sherlock Holmes summary

The story in one page

After three years of public mourning, the world's most famous consulting detective reappears to resume his practice in London. Between tracking down an air-gun assassin and deciphering cryptic messages written in dancing stick-men, the investigator applies his meticulous, often abrasive, observation skills to a string of baffling domestic and political enigmas. From the lethal scratching of a bureau keyhole to the recovery of a state-threatening document hidden in plain sight, he systematically disassembles the false narratives of both local police and desperate suspects to reveal the quiet, singular truth behind each case.

The Return of Sherlock Holmes characters

Who's who

  • Sherlock Holmes

    A man who returns from the grave to solve crimes.

  • Dr. Watson

    A loyal, perpetually surprised observer of Holmes's methods.

  • Stanley Hopkins

    A young police detective frequently corrected by Holmes.

  • Abe Slaney

    An American criminal identified through a series of stick-figure ciphers.

  • The Prime Minister

    A high-ranking official who witnesses the recovery of a secret.

The Return of Sherlock Holmes themes & meaning

What it's really about

Evidence
Observation triumphs over assumption.
Secrets
Information hidden in plain sight.

Why it's memorable

  • A man falling dead while an empty house appears occupied.
  • A letter of state discovered right where it was never lost.
The Return of Sherlock Holmes ending

The ending, explained

Spoilers — show the ending

The detective finds the missing document hidden within its own dispatch-box, then smugly refuses to explain the mechanics of his success.

The Return of Sherlock Holmes discussion questions

For your book club

  1. The detective's return is handled with more shock than logic.
  2. Police officers are consistently outperformed by a man without a badge.
Books like The Return of Sherlock Holmes

If you liked this