The Hunter's Lodge Case: A Study in Alibis

The Hunter's Lodge Case

A wealthy uncle is shot, and his heirs expect a quick inheritance and zero consequences.

Author
by Agatha Christie
Type
Short story · Detective Mystery
Published
1923
Length
Short story
Status
Public domain
The Hunter's Lodge Case summary

The story in one page

Hercule Poirot, despite being stuck in bed with influenza, takes on the case of Harrington Pace, who has been found shot dead in his remote Derbyshire shooting lodge. The Hon. Roger Havering and his wife Zoe call for help after finding the victim, yet the housekeeper, Mrs. Middleton, mysteriously flees during the investigation. Hastings investigates the scene, discovering that the weapon used was not the one originally suspected. Poirot reveals the couple staged the murder for an inheritance, using a false identity for the housekeeper. Although the pair successfully avoids prosecution due to insufficient evidence, they eventually perish in a plane crash, providing a grim, final sort of justice.

The Hunter's Lodge Case characters

Who's who

  • Hercule Poirot

    A detective who solves crimes from his bedroom.

  • Captain Hastings

    Poirot’s assistant who investigates the crime scene personally.

  • Roger Havering

    The victim’s heir who orchestrates a clever alibi.

  • Zoe Havering

    The wife who pulls the trigger on her uncle.

  • Mrs. Middleton

    A fake housekeeper who vanishes when police arrive.

The Hunter's Lodge Case themes & meaning

What it's really about

Inheritance
A primary motive for the murder.
Justice
Divine retribution when legal systems fail.

Why it's memorable

  • A detective solving a murder while bedridden with the flu.
  • A missing housekeeper whose only legacy is a box of clothes.
The Hunter's Lodge Case ending

The ending, explained

Spoilers — show the ending

The guilty pair evades human law, only to meet their end in a plane crash while flying to Paris. Justice is served by fate rather than the police.

The Hunter's Lodge Case discussion questions

For your book club

  1. Can justice ever truly be served if the law remains silent?
  2. How does a detective work when he is physically incapable of leaving his bed?
Books like The Hunter's Lodge Case

If you liked this