The Hand in the Dark: A Family Estate Goes South

The Hand in the Dark

A young wife is shot in her own bedroom, and the history of the house suggests she isn't the first.

Author
by Arthur J. Rees
Type
novel · Detective Mystery
Published
1920
Length
Long novel
Status
Public domain
The Hand in the Dark summary

The story in one page

In a damp, ancient English house, a young wife is found murdered. Police suspect the staff, but a detective named Colwyn focuses on the house's troubled occupants. The victim’s secret affection for a male relative and a coded inscription on a brooch reveal a darker history of unrequited love and hidden obsession. As evidence mounts, the investigation unravels a chain of events rooted in the family's past, ultimately pointing to a culprit whose actions were fueled by mental instability. The story explores the weight of ancestral ghosts and the cold reality of justice before reaching a final, quiet conclusion in the wake of a sudden death.

The Hand in the Dark characters

Who's who

  • Colwyn

    A sharp detective who sees through the obvious leads.

  • Philip Heredith

    A reserved man whose hidden madness drives the tragedy.

  • Hazel Rath

    A dependent household member harboring a secret, fatal affection.

  • Merrington

    A police superintendent who struggles with public pressure.

  • Miss Heredith

    The family figure who tries to maintain a sense of order.

The Hand in the Dark themes & meaning

What it's really about

Inheritance
Ancestral curses manifesting as modern criminal acts.
Secrecy
The lethal weight of keeping silent for love.

Why it's memorable

  • A bullet-burnt rest-gown revealing the close range of the shot.
  • A brooch scratched with a secret vow found on the bedroom floor.
The Hand in the Dark ending

The ending, explained

Spoilers — show the ending

Philip Heredith dies by his own hand after the truth emerges. Colwyn leaves the family to face the aftermath of his discovery.

The Hand in the Dark discussion questions

For your book club

  1. The detective avoids simplistic motives by observing the suspect's habits.
  2. Evidence often shifts as the investigators re-examine early, ignored clues.
Books like The Hand in the Dark

If you liked this